Commonfund Institute has released the 2014 Commonfund Study of Responsible Investing (CSRI): A Survey of Endowments and their Affiliated Foundations.
This new joint effort by Commonfund Institute, the National Association of College and University Business Officers and the Association of Governing Boards of Universities and Colleges provides an in-depth look into four specific areas regarding responsible investing:
• Current Investment practices
• Policies and procedures
• Views on responsible investing
• Potential future changes to portfolios
The CSRI surveyed institutions that engage in any of the following practices:
Socially responsible investing (SRI): A portfolio construction process that attempts to avoid investments in certain stocks or industries through negative screening according to defined ethical guidelines.
Environmental, social and governance (ESG) investing: An investment practice that involves integrating the three ESG factors into fundamental investment analysis to the extent that they are material to investment performance.
Impact investing: Investing in projects, companies, funds, or organizations with the express goal of generating and measuring mission-related social, environmental or economic change alongside financial return.
Divestment of fossil fuels: A type of exclusionary screening strategy through which investors actively exclude companies involved in fossil fuels from their investment portfolio.
The Study also provided opportunities to indicate whether, and how, a particular strategy at their institution differed from the defined terms.
Of the 200 institutions who participated in the Study, there were 53 “adopters” of Responsible Investing practices; and 147 “non-adopters” – institutions which, while they do not currently engage in any of the four practices, may have policies and procedures in place that relate to responsible investing, may have views on the topic, or may be considering future changes to their portfolio.
These proportions of Responsible Investing adopters vs. non-adopters may be indicative of the current state of responsible investing. An ongoing debate continues about whether responsible investing practices sacrifice potential investment return and are therefore inconsistent with trustees’ fiduciary responsibilities.
Of the four approaches to responsible investing covered by the Study, SRI was clearly the most commonly used, with ESG a significant but distant second, while the use of impact investing and divestment was negligible.
The adopter group in the 2014 CSRI contained proportionately more private than public institutions. Of the 53 adopter institutions, 42, or 79.2 per cent, are private and just 11, or 20.8 per cent, are public. Conversely, private institutions are less well-represented among the 147 non-adopters, where 81, or just 55.1 per cent, are private and 66, or 44.9 per cent, are public.
Just over half of the adopters – primarily those using SRI screens – are identifiable as faith-based institutions.
For many faith-based institutions, fiduciary duty is set in balance against – or redefined to include – the moral and ethical values that the institution seeks to advance. It is therefore not unnatural to see such institutions well represented among users of responsible investment practices.
Definitions in the responsible investing area have not yet been standardised and thus there is, as a result, some vagueness in the minds of many as to what is involved in the various responsible investing practices. This is particularly true when it comes to the difference between SRI, which relies primarily on the exclusion of investments based on an institution’s moral or ethical standards, and ESG, which seeks to include investments with certain specific desirable characteristics.
Forty participating institutions – one-fifth of the total and just over three-quarters of the adopter group – reported using Socially Responsible Investing screens. Nearly two-thirds of this group are faith-based institutions, a testament to the long-standing use of SRI screens among this constituency. The most commonly-cited screens – those used by at least 30 per cent of the group of SRI users – were those prohibiting investments related to abortion, alcohol, armaments/weapons, gambling, pornography, tobacco and unfair labour practices.
A smaller group of 17 adopters – around 8.5 per cent of total Study participants and just under one-third of the adopter group – reported integrating Environmental Social and Governance (ESG) factors into their investment decision-making. Here, the proportion of faith-based institutions, while substantial, was smaller at 47.1 per cent than that using SRI. Among the 17 ESG users, an average of 35.5 per cent of endowment assets were managed according to ESG criteria.
Low rates of adoption were reported with respect to impact investing and fossil fuel divestment. Impact investing was used by only five institutions – three private and two public – representing 2.5 per cent of total respondents and 9.4 per cent of adopters. Four of the five reported that they devoted between 1 per cent and 20 per cent of assets to impact investments. Two activities were cited specifically – community economic development investments and companies serving less-developed or underprivileged communities.
Divestment of fossil fuels, notwithstanding its prominent position in the debate surrounding responsible investing, was reported by only three institutions – two private and one public – representing 1.5 per cent of the total respondent group and 5.7 per cent of the adopters. The majority of the full group of respondents, including both adopters and non-adopters, reported that they were not concerned or only slightly concerned about exposure to a future collapse in fossil fuel companies’ value due to potential carbon regulations.
One question asked about the level of understanding of their board or investment committee of the difference between ESG integration and SRI practices. While 50 per cent of Study respondents said that their board and investment or finance committee has a “good” understanding of the difference between ESG integration and SRI practices, 18 per cent said they had no understanding, and 23 per cent responded that they did not know or were uncertain. Just eight per cent said these bodies had a complete understanding. In a similar vein, 53 per cent of Study participants neither agreed nor disagreed with the statement that ESG integration can add value to the investment process, regardless of mission-related concerns. Nineteen per cent agreed with the statement, while only eight per cent disagreed.
Study respondents indicated “substantial” impediments to greater adoption of ESG integration: 36 per cent of the total respondent group cited concern about the possibility of lower investment performance and 15 per cent identified concern about violating fiduciary duty. Thirty per cent said that lack of transparency due to investment in commingled funds was a substantial impediment, while 27 per cent cited the need for more research to determine how ESG integration affects investment returns.
This Study analyses policies, practices and attitudes with respect to responsible investing among 200 US colleges and universities, constituting 24.0 per cent of the 832 institutions that participated in the 2014 NACUBO-Commonfund Study of Endowments® (NCSE). These respondents, whose chief business officers volunteered to participate in this follow-up Study, comprised 123 private and 77 public institutions with a total of $88.8 billion in endowment assets as of June 30, 2014, or 17.2 per cent of the $516.0 billion total included in the NCSE, and encompassed a wide range of endowment sizes and geographic locations across the US