Bringing you live news and features since 2013
Bringing you news, views and analysis since 2013

36957

How SDG-aligned are ESG funds?

RELATED TOPICS​

A new report from sustainable debt firm Util has found that the holding exposure and real-world impact of ‘sustainable’ funds hardly deviates from vanilla funds – with environmental degradation the greatest casualty of all invested capital. 

The report compares the respective holdings of sustainable and total US-domiciled funds, and evaluates the degree to which each group positively and negatively contributes to the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). 

The results demonstrate that, without regulation dictating what constitutes environmental, social and governance (ESG) investing, nor how it should be integrated and addressed, funds marketed as ‘sustainable’ are commonly exposed to the same constituents as their vanilla counterparts. 

More concerning than greenwash, however, is the discovery that untempered investing is contributing to environmental degradation across the board. 

According to the repity. Greenwashing is rife. In terms of exposure and impact, the sustainable and total fund groups are similarly aligned.

At a sector, industry and company level, the sustainable funds hardly deviate from the mean—despite a higher average fee for the former. And relative goodness doesn’t translate into positive impact.

With all SDG performance aggregated, the sustainable fund group performs just two percentage points higher than the benchmark—for which end-investors pay a premium. 

Investors claim to be ESG, but there’s little mandate to match words with action or intent with impact. 

While sustainable funds have less negative impact, neither group has a significant positive impact.

The SDGs address three themes—planet, people, and prosperity (E, S and G respectively). Both fund groups have a positive impact on the four ‘prosperity’ goals, a slight positive impact on the eight ‘people’ goals and a negative impact on the five ‘planet’ goals. 

While 77 of the sustainable fund names contain the terms ‘green’, ‘clean’, ‘climate’, or ‘sustainable’, only four have a positive impact on the environmental SDGs.

Impact is complicated. There’s no such thing as a ‘good’ or ‘bad’ sector or fund—but good and bad impact arises in unexpected and unpredictable places. 

Util’s machine-learning models discovered relationships between ostensibly uncorrelated investments and SDGs. Sustainable funds are more likely to focus on female-led businesses but don’t outperform on SDG 5 because they fail to invest in female welfare globally. They’re underexposed to healthcare but outperform on SDG 3 because they’re overexposed to transport and underexposed to energy.

To achieve positive impact and avoid unintended pitfalls, portfolios must have a clear objective, address all potential outcomes and consider the full value chain of any sustainability theme. 

Latest News

Bequant has announced that it has launched a new capital introduction platform designed specifically for..
ndosuez Wealth Management has announced the launch of Indosuez Funds - Chronos Green Bonds 2028,..
New global research from industry association Global Digital Finance (GDF) shows most major financial institutions..

Related Articles

graph
The exodus from hedge funds continues with investors questioning unswayed by relatively strong performance from the alternative asset class...
The exodus from hedge funds continues with investors questioning unswayed by relatively strong performance from the alternative asset class...
Waves
A joint statement from BNP Paribas Asset Management, Federated Hermes Limited, Mirova, Robeco and Storebrand Asset Management has been published, entitled The urgent need for better ocean-related data to make informed investment decisions...
A joint statement from BNP Paribas Asset Management, Federated Hermes Limited, Mirova, Robeco and Storebrand Asset Management has been published,..
Frozen soap bubble
From the end of this month, the UK’s Sustainability Disclosure Requirements (SDR) regime comes into force which the Financial Conduct Authority says has a simple aim: “Financial products that are marketed as sustainable should do as they claim and have the evidence to back it up.”..
From the end of this month, the UK’s Sustainability Disclosure Requirements (SDR) regime comes into force which the Financial Conduct..
Global ESG Investing
On May 15 Florida’s Republican Governor Ron DeSantis signed legislation that furthers his ongoing campaign to oppose the role of climate change and ESG factors in state policymaking...
On May 15 Florida’s Republican Governor Ron DeSantis signed legislation that furthers his ongoing campaign to oppose the role of..
Subscribe to the Institutional Asset Manager newsletter

Subscribe for access to our weekly newsletter, newsletter archive, updates on the site and exclusive email content.

Marketing by