Bringing you news, views and analysis since 2013

30104

M&A activity slowing in run up to Brexit, says Jefferies

RELATED TOPICS​

Despite a strong year for M&A in 2018, things are slowing in the run-up to Brexit at the end of March, according to the latest M&A report from Jefferies.

The firm writes that this is most keenly felt by UK companies heavily exposed to the UK economy.

“For example, Brexit-related concerns were cited as a significant reason for the consortium including Brookfield pulling its GBP2.9 billion takeover of Intu Properties at the end of last year, albeit the retail property sector is also battling structural headwinds unrelated to Brexit.”

The report says that UK companies with more global businesses are less directly impacted although the availability of financing for

transactions came into focus for all companies and sponsors over the turn of the year, with significant dislocation in the equity and leveraged finance markets. 

“In general, as the key decision-making period for UK and EU policymakers is now upon us, the desire to wait to see the outcome of the Brexit-process is now, in many cases, overriding the impetus to undertake M&A transactions. At the time of writing, the range of potential outcomes to the Brexit process still seems very wide (with a potential second referendum even moving higher up the agenda) and is matched by the range of possible implications for the UK M&A market. 

“What does seem clear is that 2019 will bring some form of Brexit milestone(s) that will help set the future direction, both of the UK in general, and of the UK M&A market specifically. We suspect that any form of orderly exit from the EU would unlock a significant number of UK M&A transactions as pent up demand works its way through.”

However, a disorderly or delayed Brexit would prolong the current period of uncertainty and act as an obstacle to the progress of many potential transactions, the firm says. 

Shareholder activism might increase if there is a disorderly Brexit, the firm says. Activist funds originated in the US but have become increasingly prevalent in the UK and Europe as they have sought opportunities outside of the US. 

“This trend continued in 2018 with activists taking positions in prominent companies such Barclays (Sherborne), Whitbread (Elliott), Micro Focus (Elliott), Merlin Entertainments (ValueAct), BT (Greenlight) and, most recently, the building materials giant CRH (Cevian).”

Jefferies also reports that they are seeing increased interest from private equity in UK take-private transactions. Of the 42 firm offers for UK public companies announced in 2018, 13 firm offers (31 per cent) were made by private equity. These included Silver Lake’s GBP2.2 billion takeover of ZPG where Jefferies acted as financial adviser to ZPG. Other notable deals were Bain’s GBP1.2 billion acquisition of esure and Advent’s GBP1 billion acquisition of Laird. PE interest is also being fuelled by a significantly improved leveraged finance market in the last few weeks following the hiatus during the December– January period.

The firm writes that PE funds have become increasingly accustomed to the new landscape for UK public transactions post the significant Takeover Code changes in 2011. This includes mandatory ‘put up or shut up’ timetables, public display of financing documentation and reduced deal protection measures. Partly, this has been out of necessity, as an increasing number of well-capitalised PE funds seek opportunities to deploy their substantial firepower into what has been a sellers’ market in recent years.

Finally, Jefferies notes that an increased public-to-private transactions may also be an unintended consequence of MiFID II.

Since its introduction at the beginning of 2018, it has aimed at ‘unbundling’ sell-side research costs from trading costs to increase transparency in the fund management industry. 

The legislation has forced banks and brokers to directly charge the buyside for their equity research for the first time, Jefferies writes. At the same time, fund managers have had to decide which research to pay for and whether to allocate costs to their funds or their own P&Ls, with most choosing their own P&Ls. In turn, this has forced fund managers to reassess their use of research.

“A year following implementation, MiFID II has resulted in a general decline in the volume of sell-side research as the fund management industry has chosen to scale back on its external research consumption. BlackRock, the world’s largest investment company, recently announced that it had cut its research budget for EMEA by almost 60 per cent last year. The sell-side has started to react to this by further shifting research coverage towards the larger end of the company market capitalisation scale. At the smaller end of the market, MiFID II also seems to have been a catalyst for further broker consolidation with reduced sell-side research capacity an inevitable result.”

Jefferies notes that, perhaps as an unintended consequence, less research at the smaller end of the size spectrum has started to result in lower demand and liquidity for small and mid-cap stocks and, arguably, less efficient price formation. In 2018, the mid-caps’ share of total volumes on the main market of the London Stock Exchange fell from around 18 per cent to less than 13 per cent.

“A number of commentators have argued that reducing the number of brokers and banks producing research on stocks will lead to more mispricing opportunities for active investors prepared to do their own due diligence on smaller companies. 

“We would extend this argument and also suggest that mis-pricing opportunities are likely to lead to increased opportunism from private equity investors around take-private transactions. For similar reasons, PE firms may be pushing on open doors as management teams of smaller listed companies increasingly struggle to achieve a fair rating for their stock and also conclude that their shares are not fit for purpose as an acquisition currency or remuneration tool. 

“In combination, ambitious CEOs, as well as frustrated founders, may conclude that their companies are better suited to private ownership and the ability this often affords to invest in the business on a longer-term horizon than public markets allow. As an additional pull factor, private equity remuneration structures can still be significantly more attractive for senior managers than what a public company can offer.”

Jefferies also notes that as more companies are taken private or leave the market one might also expect this to lead to a lower population of listed companies in the UK – if smaller companies are unable to attract suitable analyst (and by extension, investor) attention, a significant reason for being listed is undermined. 

And the facts show that the total population of London Listed Companies has already fallen by 20 per cent over the 10 years from 2008 – 2018 (from 2,626 companies to 2,089), with the majority of the decline being driven by smaller companies leaving. This trend is being accentuated by the rise of passive investment funds which tend to concentrate investments at the larger end of the market capitalisation scale, Jefferies says.

Latest News

Nearly nine in 10 (88 per cent) of private capital general partners (GPs) surveyed say..
Hedge funds posted mixed declines in October, with sharp drops in Technology and AI-related equities..
The UK is poised to become one of the world’s next generation of fintech leaders,..

Related Articles

European investors continue to the lead the charge for sustainable investing, ploughing USD9.4 billion into funds in the third quarter of 2026...
European investors continue to the lead the charge for sustainable investing, ploughing USD9.4 billion into funds in the third quarter..
Asset managers gave a muted response to the UK Budget from Chancellor of the Exchequer John Healey this week, with one describing it as a “non-event”...
Asset managers gave a muted response to the UK Budget from Chancellor of the Exchequer John Healey this week, with..
It is tough out there for asset managers and it is about to get tougher, according to research from PwC...
It is tough out there for asset managers and it is about to get tougher, according to research from PwC...
Asset managers ever more reliant on artificial intelligence (AI) to support their investment decisions are becoming more vulnerable to weaker data that informs the technology...
Asset managers ever more reliant on artificial intelligence (AI) to support their investment decisions are becoming more vulnerable to weaker..

Subscribe to the Institutional Asset Manager newsletter

Subscribe for access to our weekly newsletter, newsletter archive, updates on the site and exclusive email content.

Marketing by