A new white paper from bfinance finds that infrastructure managers are increasingly taking on more and different types of risk to try and ensure returns at least match past performance.
The firm writes that following a period of post-crisis expansion, the infrastructure sector has now entered a dramatically different era, termed ‘Infrastructure 3.0’ by this new paper.
Alongside the much-anticipated compression in potential returns and strategy drift, as well as a recent dip in capital raising, today’s market features a far more diverse, segmented universe of available funds, the firm says. “As today’s managers take on more risk and different types of risk to try and ensure returns at least match past performance, investors are grappling with an evolving opportunity set.
“For those selecting asset managers, such as the investors whose searches are explored in this paper, the new climate opens up new questions. Allocators are increasingly asking whether their manager is overpaying for assets, whether certain funds are too large for their intended strategies, whether an appropriate premium is still available for illiquidity and how much greenfield or non-OECD exposure is appropriate. Expectations for return, risk and diversification characteristics should be based on current market realities, not historical results.”
Against this backdrop bfinance recommends three further ‘key takeaways’ to guide investors as they attempt to navigate this more complex infrastructure investment landscape.
“Managers’ strategies are changing and evolving to cope with new market conditions. Although this may not necessarily pose a problem, investors should take great care to ensure that teams are well placed to handle the change in pace.
“Investors should be suitably sceptical about sourcing and bid discipline since few if any managers are genuinely insulated from today’s high prices and stated figures for ‘off-market’ deals are often inflated. Opportunities such as the dislocation in pricing of midstream energy MLPs in the US are likely to be unusual.
“The market for infrastructure investments in esoteric sub-sectors can be deeper and broader than investors may expect. One search presented in the paper (‘Entering Renewables’) illustrates the point, with the investor able to choose from a universe of funds nearly three times larger than the investment consultant had indicated.”
The paper finds that there has been a significant compression in unlisted infrastructure returns since the post-crisis period. Returns for ‘core’ infrastructure are now approximately 4-7 per cent, down from 6-9 per cent. ‘Core-plus’ infrastructure should now deliver roughly 8-12 per cent, in comparison with 10-15 per cent previously. Value-added infrastructure may be expected to give returns above 12 per cent – formerly 15 per cent or higher.
The three case studies in the paper examine very different infrastructure mandates and each provides tactical insight into how investors are addressing the selection of managers in this more varied, challenging infrastructure investment environment.
The first search – ‘over-priced opportunities’ – involved a Canadian foundation seeking a comprehensive review of the unlisted infrastructure manager universe intending to allocate approximately $40 million to one or possibly two mangers via an open-ended or closed-ended pool fund. The investor’s chief concern was determining whether the preferred manager was over-paying for assets in a high valuation environment.
Search two – ‘combining exposures’ – involved a UK Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) seeking to add new infrastructure investments alongside an existing portfolio and find opportunities that would complement current holdings. The investor also sought an analysis comparing the US and European markets, including differences in sourcing, staffing and deal type.
The third case study looks – ‘entering renewables’– examines a renewable energy infrastructure search for a European pension fund. The authors writes that this niche provides an excellent example of sub-sector-specific manager proliferation – a key trend in recent years with specialist expertise proving increasingly critical to return generation.
“Yet the dynamics of the renewable space are changing, with the number of new projects in conventional technologies supported by generous subsidy regimes beginning to slow down and some managers already targeting other segments of the renewable energy value chain that aren’t necessarily supported by long-term contracts and, as such, entail a greater level of risk.”
Although there has been a dip in capital raising, bfinance expects the appetite for this asset class to continue. Given the weight of capital flowing into the asset class, the report’s authors expect investor appetite for private infrastructure to remain strong through 2017, with bfinance having been engaged in infrastructure manager selection engagements totalling over USD600 million reflecting the continuing high demand for the sector. The infrastructure market has undergone major upheaval, becoming increasingly segmented and with potential for strategy drift. It is therefore critical that investors are equipped to scrutinise its evolving risk exposures, return expectations and correlation characteristics.
Anish Butani, Infrastructure Specialist, says: “While infrastructure has become an increasingly significant component of pension fund, endowment and sovereign wealth fund portfolios over the past decade, investors today face an increasingly challenging and diverse opportunity set.
“With surging deal activity driving down returns, particularly for the most prized core infrastructure assets, infrastructure funds that have traditionally been active in the sector are being pushed to work harder to source the types of deals that will generate the returns that they have enjoyed in the past. Indeed, in a ‘lower for longer’ rate environment, the ability of managers to generate ‘alpha’ is increasingly under the microscope, with investors seeking more clarity on key drivers of performance of predecessor funds.
“To what extent have valuation uplifts been driven by macroeconomic tailwinds (such as falling risk free rates, benign financing markets and healthy inflation rates)? How much can be attributed to business plan outperformance? How experienced is the investment team in executing a specialist strategy or in newer geographies? These questions, coupled with the proliferation of choice available to investors, make understanding the risks involved when allocating capital to the sector as – if not more – important today than ever.”
Guy Hopgood, Senior Associate, Private Markets, says: “As investors are becoming more savvy and knowledgeable about the asset class, we are also witnessing a proliferation in the strategies that they have to choose from. Whereas investors started off by wanting a tick in the infrastructure ‘box’, we are now seeing demand for more niche and specialist products, with asset managers quick to pick up on this. Whilst there are obvious benefits to this, with managers able to focus tirelessly on their specific market and geography, it has added far more choice to the universe which investors now need to navigate. Although infrastructure is viewed as a single asset class, the sub-sectors within it are not homogeneous, and understanding the nuances in each is key.”