In the latest edition of Global Horizons, Standard Life Investments considers the issue of benchmark choice in the light of the evolution towards an absolute return style of investing.
Conventionally fund management benchmarks either reference a market index or consist of a peer comparison, this serves as a measure of the fund managers relative success.
However in absolute return investing they are usually couched in terms of cash comparisons, this is presumably intended to reflect the manager’s absolute success against client goals.
In the report Standard Life Investments considers how appropriate this is, and asks whether setting the benchmark in real or nominal terms now makes more sense.
Brian Fleming, head of multi-asset risk and structuring at Standard Life Investments, says: “Our analysis has taken us from establishing that investor goals may generally be expressed as a desire for superior risk-adjusted returns relative to a benchmark to determining what form that benchmark might take. Starting from a wide array of individually tailored liability benchmarks it is possible, by hedging out interest-rate and inflation risks, to arrive at a more generally applicable absolute-return benchmark.
“The choice of an appropriate benchmark has evolved and been refined over time. We have established that there are good reasons why nominal risk-free rates are preferred to real. In an environment of persistent low inflation, real returns on risky assets are not far removed from nominal returns so this issue becomes less contentious. However other practical considerations such as investibility dictate the ultimate choice. We expect to see further convergence towards shorter term cash-related benchmarks over time.”
Frances Hudson, global thematic strategist, adds: “Looking ahead, it is useful to consider what might cause a change in benchmark. The experience with Libor spreads where banks stopped lending to each other and the interbank market seized up during the global financial crisis provided an object lesson in why a more liquid market is preferred as the relevant benchmark. Similarly, post financial crisis we are cognisant of the potential discrepancies between cash deposit and government bill rates.
“A key question for investment managers is how close to the benchmark should performance be over any given time period? Does substantial outperformance always suggest that too much risk is being taken? Part of the answer may lie in the contrast between benchmarks, which are becoming more short term, and therefore less risky, in the quest for investibility, and the often longer term views which managers must take in order to access better return opportunities. We know that equity risk premia can deviate substantially from long-term averages for quite prolonged periods so delivering long-term objectives may be consistent with divergence.”